Penis envy
- Concept · Psychoanalysis
- Historical theory
- Published October 19, 2026
- 19 sources
- 5 min read
In short
Related in this topic
On this page
Key facts
- Field
- Psychoanalysis
- Originators
- Sigmund Freud
- First described
- 1925
- Also known as
- Female castration complex; Masculinity complex
- Topics
- Psychoanalysis
State of the evidence
Historical theoryFreud’s claim that penis envy organizes female development has been abandoned by most psychoanalytic writers, who place a core sense of femininity earlier and treat penis envy as one fantasy among others rather than a foundation[1][2][3][4]. Empirical tests are few, rest on projective tests, dream coding and analogue tasks, and are mixed: a 1966 classroom finding was not replicated[5], and a cross-cultural dream study linked penis envy imagery to women’s social status rather than anatomy[6].
Evidence labels summarise the research literature; they are not recommendations. How labels are assigned
Penis envy is, in Sigmund Freud’s psychoanalytic theory, a girl’s envy of the penis, which he held arises when she discovers the anatomical difference between the sexes. Freud allocated the two reactions to that discovery by sex: fear of castration to the boy and envy of the penis to the girl[7]. He made penis envy a turning point in his account of female development. The same constellation is also called the female castration complex or the masculinity complex[8].
The concept belongs to Freud’s theory of the Oedipus complex, whose female form Carl Jung named the Electra complex, and to his stage theory of psychosexual development. Those entries cover the wider theory.
Freud’s account of female development
Freud first presented his developed ideas on femininity in “Some Psychical Consequences of the Anatomical Distinction between the Sexes” (1925). The paper provoked controversy among psychoanalysts, and he returned to the subject in “Female Sexuality” (1931) and in the lecture “Femininity” (1933), which restates penis envy alongside his views on bisexuality, passivity and activity[9]. What was new in “Femininity”, compared with his account of 1905 in the Three Essays on the Theory of Sexuality, was the weight he gave to the girl’s intense early attachment to her mother, from which he thought she never entirely breaks free[9].
A further step, in traditional psychoanalytic theory, is the substitution of a wish for a baby for the original wish for a penis, an idea known as the penis–baby equation[10]. Freud described three possible outcomes of the girl’s Oedipal conflict: a neurotic solution, a “masculinity complex”, or a normal feminine attitude that, in his account, involved acceptance of anatomical inferiority together with passivity, masochism and narcissism[11].
Horney and womb envy
The concept was disputed within psychoanalysis during Freud’s lifetime. Some of his colleagues accused him of male bias for failing to see the envy that men feel toward women[12]. Karen Horney was among them: as part of her critique of male bias in psychoanalysis, she proposed that men envy women’s capacity to bear and nurture children[13][14][12]. In her 1926 paper she argued that men had subjugated women and excluded them from social and political power because of that envy[12]. Her essays “The Flight from Womanhood” (1926) and “The Dread of Woman” (1932) influenced psychoanalysts and students of culture[15].
Later writers call this counterpart womb envy, meaning male envy of the female reproductive capacity. Semmelhack and colleagues credit Horney’s 1926 paper with stirring interest in it as part of her critique of male bias, and note that Edith Jacobson and Melanie Klein also addressed it; in Klein’s version, the male infant’s envy of the breast later becomes envy of the mother’s capacity to bear children[14]. Balsam groups Horney with Margarete Hilferding and Otto Rank as early analysts who tried to shift Freud’s beliefs about women’s bodies, including the place of childbirth, and attributes his disputes with them partly to his loyalty to a phallus-centered theory[16].
Clara Thompson offered a different reformulation in papers from 1941 to 1950: what women envy is not male anatomy but male status and power, for which the penis is a convenient symbol[6].
Revisions within psychoanalysis
A 1976 supplement of the Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association brought together several revisions. Kleeman reviewed Freud’s claims against direct observation of young children and concluded that cognitive functions, learning and language matter more than Freud allowed, and that penis envy and feelings of inferiority have a less universal and less necessary place in the onset of femininity[1]. Stoller argued that Freud’s chronology omits the first months of life, in which a fixed sense of being female is established through factors including sex assignment and parental attitudes; he accepted that penis envy and castration anxiety are easy to demonstrate clinically, but argued that a first, nonconflictual phase of femininity precedes the conflicts of the Oedipal period[2]. Grossman and Stewart distinguished an early phase of penis envy, experienced as a narcissistic injury that can be resolved, from a later, regressive phase, and argued that penis envy should be analyzed as the manifest content of a symptom rather than treated as “bedrock”[17].
By 1989 a review could summarize modern psychoanalytic opinion as treating penis envy as a normal developmental phase that most women resolve, and as finding that women develop strong, if different, superego structures[11]. Tyson proposed that primary femininity, rather than an innate bisexuality, be considered the bedrock of female psychology[4]. Dahl described current scholarship as rejecting recognition of the genital difference as central to femininity, partly because child-observational research shows that gender identity is acquired by age three, and partly because interpretations organized around penis envy appeared to have little effect in the analysis of adult women[3]. In her account, the fantasies the term refers to are one defensive response to awareness of bodily and generational limits, not the basis of femininity[3]. Others have reinterpreted the concept rather than discarding it. Zepf and Seel, following Laplanche, recast penis envy as arising from the girl’s rivalries within the family and from her identification with her parents’ own Oedipal conflicts[18].
Feminist critiques
Feminist psychoanalysts produced several alternative accounts of sexual difference. Brunner examines four, by Horney, Nancy Chodorow, Luce Irigaray and Jessica Benjamin, against Freud’s division of fear and envy between the sexes, while arguing that even a widely maligned myth may still offer material for thought[7]. Schafer, writing from within psychoanalysis, concluded that Freud’s ideas on women were flawed by patriarchal and evolutionary values: questionable presuppositions, logical errors, neglect of development before the phallic stage, and an automatic linkage of femininity with passivity and masochism[19].
Feminists have also divided over what the concept describes. Some read Freud as denigrating women; others, including Juliet Mitchell in 1974, read him as describing women’s position in societies that treated them as second-class[12].
Empirical studies
Attempts to test the concept have been few, and most infer penis envy indirectly. In a 1966 study, 26 unmarried career women in traditionally masculine occupations scored higher than 25 homemakers on a Rorschach-based measure of the female castration complex, including its penis envy component[8]. In the same year, Johnson reported that more women than men failed to return special pencils after an examination and suggested that keeping them might express penis envy; a later replication did not support that conclusion[5].
Two studies tested reformulations. Nathan coded dreams of women from 20 cultures and found that penis envy imagery was less frequent where women’s social status was higher, which she took as support for Thompson’s view; in men’s dreams the imagery varied with the visibility of sex differences instead[6]. Jones exposed college students to subliminal or supraliminal messages about pregnancy or penetration. Women who received the subliminal pregnancy message gave more phallic imagery in responses to inkblots than women in the other conditions, a result she interpreted as consistent with the penis–baby equation[10].
These studies rely on projective tests, coded dream reports and analogue tasks, and none tested the developmental sequence Freud proposed. The evidence that changed psychoanalytic opinion came instead from child observation, which found a core gender identity established by about the age of three, earlier than Freud’s account allowed[1][2][3].
Sources19
Numbered in order of first citation.
- 1.Kleeman, J. A. (1976). Freud’s views on early female sexuality in the light of direct child observation. Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association. pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/803149/
- 2.Stoller, R. J. (1976). Primary femininity. Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association. pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/803151/
- 3.Dahl, E. K. (1996). The concept of penis envy revisited: A child analyst listens to adult women. The Psychoanalytic Study of the Child, 51(1), 303–325. https://doi.org/10.1080/00797308.1996.11822433
- 4.Tyson, P. (1994). Bedrock and beyond: An examination of the clinical utility of contemporary theories of female psychology. Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association, 42(2), 447–467. https://doi.org/10.1177/000306519404200206
- 5.Skinner, N. F. (1997). Failure to support a test for penis envy. Psychological Reports, 80(3), 754. https://doi.org/10.2466/pr0.1997.80.3.754
- 6.Nathan, S. G. (1981). Cross-cultural perspectives on penis envy. Psychiatry, 44(1), 39–44. https://doi.org/10.1080/00332747.1981.11024090
- 7.Brunner, J. (1997). Fear and envy: Sexual difference and the economies of feminist critique in psychoanalytic discourse. Science in Context, 10(1), 129–170. https://doi.org/10.1017/s0269889700000302
- 8.Levin, R. B. (1966). An empirical test of the female castration complex. Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 71(3), 181–188. https://doi.org/10.1037/h0023386
- 9.Minsky, R. (2014). Sigmund Freud: ‘Femininity’ (1933). In Psychoanalysis and Gender (pp. 231–251). Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9780203754061-18
- 10.Jones, R. L. (1994). An empirical study of Freud’s penis-baby equation. The Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease, 182(3), 127–135. https://doi.org/10.1097/00005053-199403000-00001
- 11.Small, F. E. (1989). The psychology of women: A psychoanalytic review. The Canadian Journal of Psychiatry, 34(9), 872–878. https://doi.org/10.1177/070674378903400906
- 12.Maguire, M. (1997). Envy between women. In Psychotherapy with Women (pp. 74–94). Macmillan Education UK. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-349-25615-0_5
- 13.Horney, K. (1967). Feminine psychology. W. W. Norton.
- 14.Semmelhack, D., Ende, L., Farrell, K., & Pojas, J. (2011). Womb envy and Western society: On the devaluation of nurturing in psychotherapy and society. Europe’s Journal of Psychology, 7(1), 164–186. https://doi.org/10.5964/ejop.v7i1.110
- 15.Janowitz, N. (2025). Horney’s dread and envy of women: looking backwards and forwards. The American Journal of Psychoanalysis, 85(2), 236–247. https://doi.org/10.1057/s11231-025-09514-9
- 16.Balsam, R. (2013). Freud, females, childbirth, and dissidence: Margarete Hilferding, Karen Horney, and Otto Rank. The Psychoanalytic Review, 100(5), 695–716. https://doi.org/10.1521/prev.2013.100.5.695
- 17.Grossman, W. I., & Stewart, W. A. (1976). Penis envy: From childhood wish to developmental metaphor. Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association. pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/803143/
- 18.Zepf, S., & Seel, D. (2016). Penis envy and the female Oedipus complex: A plea to reawaken an ineffectual debate. The Psychoanalytic Review, 103(3), 397–421. https://doi.org/10.1521/prev.2016.103.3.397
- 19.Schafer, R. (2019). Problems in Freud’s psychology of women. Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association, 67(3), 503–526. https://doi.org/10.1177/0003065119858947
Further reading
- Brunner, J. (1997). Fear and envy: Sexual difference and the economies of feminist critique in psychoanalytic discourse. Science in Context, 10(1), 129–170. https://doi.org/10.1017/s0269889700000302
- Dahl, E. K. (1996). The concept of penis envy revisited: A child analyst listens to adult women. The Psychoanalytic Study of the Child, 51(1), 303–325. https://doi.org/10.1080/00797308.1996.11822433
- Schafer, R. (2019). Problems in Freud’s psychology of women. Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association, 67(3), 503–526. https://doi.org/10.1177/0003065119858947
Related entries 7
- Oedipus complexConcept
- Electra complexConcept
- Psychosexual stagesConcept
- Sigmund FreudFigure
- Karen HorneyFigure
- Id, ego and superegoConcept
- PsychoanalysisTopic
Cite this entry
APA 7
Psych Dictionary. (2026, October 19). Penis envy. In Psych Dictionary. https://www.psychdictionary.com/concepts/penis-envy
MLA 9
“Penis Envy.” Psych Dictionary, 19 Oct. 2026, www.psychdictionary.com/concepts/penis-envy.