Positive vs negative punishment
- Comparison
- Published October 19, 2026
- 9 sources
- 4 min read
In short
Related in this topic
On this page
Key facts
- Compares
- Operant conditioning
- Topics
- Behaviorism
What follows the behavior
- Positive punishment
- A stimulus is added, such as a shock, a loud noise or a reprimand
- Negative punishment
- A reinforcer is taken away, or access to reinforcement is suspended for a time
Skinner’s description of the operation
- Positive punishment
- Presenting a negative reinforcer
- Negative punishment
- Withdrawing a positive reinforcer
Effect on the behavior
- Positive punishment
- Less likely to occur, when the procedure functions as a punisher
- Negative punishment
- Less likely to occur, when the procedure functions as a punisher
Meaning of the label
- Positive punishment
- “Positive” means something is added
- Negative punishment
- “Negative” means something is removed; it is not the same as negative reinforcement, which strengthens behavior
Typical procedures
- Positive punishment
- Physical punishment and reprimands; electric shock in laboratory work
- Negative punishment
- Time-out from positive reinforcement; response cost, such as fines or the loss of tokens
Laboratory example
- Positive punishment
- Food-maintained responses are also punished after every nth response (fixed-ratio punishment)
- Negative punishment
- Pigeons working for tokens lose a token after every second response
Main body of research on children
- Positive punishment
- Meta-analyses of parental corporal punishment and spanking
- Negative punishment
- Studies of time-out in parent training
Side effects most discussed
- Positive punishment
- Emotional responses, escape and avoidance, and aggression, argued by Skinner and Sidman; how general they are is disputed
- Negative punishment
- For time-out, disputed concerns about attachment security and children with trauma histories
Positive punishment
- What follows the behavior
- A stimulus is added, such as a shock, a loud noise or a reprimand
- Skinner’s description of the operation
- Presenting a negative reinforcer
- Effect on the behavior
- Less likely to occur, when the procedure functions as a punisher
- Meaning of the label
- “Positive” means something is added
- Typical procedures
- Physical punishment and reprimands; electric shock in laboratory work
- Laboratory example
- Food-maintained responses are also punished after every nth response (fixed-ratio punishment)
- Main body of research on children
- Meta-analyses of parental corporal punishment and spanking
- Side effects most discussed
- Emotional responses, escape and avoidance, and aggression, argued by Skinner and Sidman; how general they are is disputed
Negative punishment
- What follows the behavior
- A reinforcer is taken away, or access to reinforcement is suspended for a time
- Skinner’s description of the operation
- Withdrawing a positive reinforcer
- Effect on the behavior
- Less likely to occur, when the procedure functions as a punisher
- Meaning of the label
- “Negative” means something is removed; it is not the same as negative reinforcement, which strengthens behavior
- Typical procedures
- Time-out from positive reinforcement; response cost, such as fines or the loss of tokens
- Laboratory example
- Pigeons working for tokens lose a token after every second response
- Main body of research on children
- Studies of time-out in parent training
- Side effects most discussed
- For time-out, disputed concerns about attachment security and children with trauma histories
Positive and negative punishment are the two ways of punishing a behavior in operant conditioning. In positive punishment, the behavior is followed by an aversive stimulus. In negative punishment, the behavior is followed by the loss of a reinforcer. B. F. Skinner described punishment as exactly these two operations: presenting a negative reinforcer, or withdrawing a positive one[1]. Both are punishment because they make the behavior less likely. The words “positive” and “negative” say only whether something is added or taken away[2].
Figure 1Reinforcement increases the behavior it follows and punishment decreases it; “positive” and “negative” say whether a stimulus is added or removed. After Skinner (1953).
Text description
A two-by-two grid. The columns say whether a consequence adds a stimulus or removes one; the rows say whether that stimulus is appetitive, such as food, or aversive, such as a loud noise. Adding an appetitive stimulus is positive reinforcement, and the behavior increases. Removing an appetitive stimulus is negative punishment, and the behavior decreases. Adding an aversive stimulus is positive punishment, and the behavior decreases. Removing an aversive stimulus is negative reinforcement, and the behavior increases. The two reinforcement cells lie on one diagonal. A note states that positive and negative mean added and removed, not good and bad.
The two kinds of punishment occupy the two punishment cells of the diagram. Negative punishment is often confused with negative reinforcement, which removes an aversive stimulus and strengthens behavior; that distinction is set out in negative reinforcement vs punishment. Teaching articles attribute part of the confusion to Skinner having described two types of reinforcement but only one of punishment. Naming both types of punishment, they argue, makes clear that negative reinforcement is not a synonym for it[2].
Definitions and labels
Skinner defined punishment by its operations, not its effect, so that whether it weakens behavior remained a question for experiment[1]. This entry, like the comparison of negative reinforcement and punishment, defines a punisher by its effect instead: a consequence counts as a punisher only if the behavior it follows becomes less frequent. On that definition, a reprimand followed by more of the reprimanded behavior is not functioning as positive punishment. Likewise, a time-out followed by more of the behavior is not functioning as negative punishment.
Conditioned reinforcers fit the same scheme. Skinner’s examples were disapproval and taking money away in a legal fine, which on the added-or-removed logic are positive and negative punishment respectively. He also noted that punishment need not be administered by another person: a child who touches a flame is punished by the burn[1].
Laboratory findings
In one laboratory series on positive punishment, responses maintained by food on a variable-interval schedule were also punished after every nth response. Responding first accelerated between punishments and then settled into a uniform but reduced rate. The degree of suppression depended on the intensity of punishment, the ratio of punished responses and the level of food deprivation. Intermittent punishment suppressed responding less rapidly and less completely than punishing every response[3]. Skinner argued that punishment in everyday life is likely to be intermittent, because it depends on other people[1].
Negative punishment has been studied as response cost. In one experiment, four pigeons earned tokens that could be exchanged for food, and in one component of the schedule lost a token after every second response. Response rates fell selectively in that component. In control conditions, the density of tokens and food, or the rate of token loss, was matched without any contingency between responding and loss. Response rates fell less, which indicates that the contingent loss itself functioned as a punisher[4].
In both cases, Skinner’s view was that punishment suppresses behavior temporarily rather than removing it; the argument and its evidence are summarized in negative reinforcement vs punishment[1] .
Side effects in theory and evidence
Skinner held that the aversive stimuli punishment requires generate emotions, including tendencies to escape or retaliate, and disabling anxieties[1]. He described conflict between the punished response and the response that avoids punishment, especially when punishment is intermittent, and fear and anxiety reflexes evoked when punished behavior begins[1]. Murray Sidman later argued against punishment on similar grounds: the temporary nature of suppression, the dangers of conditioned punishment, increases in escape and avoidance, punishment-induced aggression and countercontrol[5].
A 2021 reappraisal of the data behind Sidman’s concerns judged them reasonable, but found little strong empirical support for the view that these problems are ubiquitous, long-lasting or specific to punishment[5]. An earlier review of basic and applied research reached a related conclusion: punishment processes need to be better understood before a systematic, effective technology of behavior change can rest on them[6].
Research on punishment of children
Much of the human research concerns parents’ discipline, and the two kinds of punishment have been studied in different literatures. Positive punishment appears mainly as corporal punishment. A 2002 meta-analysis found that parental corporal punishment was associated with higher levels of immediate compliance and of aggression, and with lower levels of moral internalization and mental health. The author proposed a model of how it might cause these outcomes and considered alternative explanations[7]. A 2016 set of meta-analyses of spanking, covering 111 effect sizes from 160,927 children, found that 13 of 17 mean effects differed significantly from zero, all in the direction of detrimental outcomes. The effects did not differ substantially from those for physical abuse or by study design[8]. The meta-analyses report associations; the 2016 analysis addressed the question of causation in part by testing whether the effects held across study designs[8].
Negative punishment appears mainly as time-out from positive reinforcement. Mark Dadds and Lucy Tully describe time-out as one of the most common and well-researched discipline procedures, with strong evidence for its efficacy and acceptability. They also note recent criticism, based on attachment theory, that removing a child to time-out breaks attachment security and may harm children with trauma histories[9]. Their analysis argues that time-out, used consistently with current models of learning, attachment and self-regulation, generally supports a child’s well-being[9]. The dispute, as they describe it, concerns possible harm to attachment security rather than efficacy[9].
Sources9
Numbered in order of first citation.
- 1.Skinner, B. F. (1953). Science and human behavior. Macmillan.
- 2.McConnell, J. V. (1990). Negative reinforcement and positive punishment. Teaching of Psychology, 17(4), 247–249. https://doi.org/10.1207/s15328023top1704_10
- 3.Azrin, N. H., Holz, W. C., & Hake, D. F. (1963). Fixed-ratio punishment. Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 6(2), 141–148. https://doi.org/10.1901/jeab.1963.6-141
- 4.Raiff, B. R., Bullock, C. E., & Hackenberg, T. D. (2008). Response-cost punishment with pigeons: Further evidence of response suppression via token loss. Learning & Behavior, 36(1), 29–41. https://doi.org/10.3758/lb.36.1.29
- 5.Fontes, R. M., & Shahan, T. A. (2021). Punishment and its putative fallout: A reappraisal. Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 115(1), 185–203. https://doi.org/10.1002/jeab.653
- 6.Lerman, D. C., & Vorndran, C. M. (2002). On the status of knowledge for using punishment: Implications for treating behavior disorders. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 35(4), 431–464. https://doi.org/10.1901/jaba.2002.35-431
- 7.Gershoff, E. T. (2002). Corporal punishment by parents and associated child behaviors and experiences: A meta-analytic and theoretical review. Psychological Bulletin, 128(4), 539–579. https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-2909.128.4.539
- 8.Gershoff, E. T., & Grogan-Kaylor, A. (2016). Spanking and child outcomes: Old controversies and new meta-analyses. Journal of Family Psychology, 30(4), 453–469. https://doi.org/10.1037/fam0000191
- 9.Dadds, M. R., & Tully, L. A. (2019). What is it to discipline a child: What should it be? A reanalysis of time-out from the perspective of child mental health, attachment, and trauma. American Psychologist, 74(7), 794–808. https://doi.org/10.1037/amp0000449
Related entries 4
- Operant conditioningConcept
- Negative reinforcement vs punishmentComparison
- B. F. SkinnerFigure
- Schedules of reinforcementConcept
Cite this entry
APA 7
Psych Dictionary. (2026, October 19). Positive vs negative punishment. In Psych Dictionary. https://www.psychdictionary.com/compare/positive-vs-negative-punishment
MLA 9
“Positive vs Negative Punishment.” Psych Dictionary, 19 Oct. 2026, www.psychdictionary.com/compare/positive-vs-negative-punishment.