EMDR vs brainspotting
- Comparison
- Published October 19, 2026
- 14 sources
- 3 min read
In short
Related in this topic
On this page
Key facts
- Topics
- Trauma-focused therapies
Developer and date
- EMDR
- Francine Shapiro; first published in 1989 as eye movement desensitization
- BSP
- David Grand, in 2003, drawing on his EMDR practice and training in somatic experiencing
What the eyes do
- EMDR
- Repeated rhythmic eye movements, or alternating taps or tones, while the memory is held in mind
- BSP
- The gaze is held still on one eye position, a brainspot, found by moving a pointer across the visual field
Target of treatment
- EMDR
- Specific traumatic memories, processed within an eight-phase protocol
- BSP
- The eye position linked to bodily activation, rather than the memory itself
Developers’ proposed mechanism
- EMDR
- Adaptive information processing, in which dysfunctionally stored memories are integrated with adaptive information
- BSP
- Midbrain pathways to the thalamus and cortex that are said to reset the orienting response to a traumatic memory
Independent mechanism research
- EMDR
- Laboratory studies attribute the effect to the working memory load of a dual task, with the direction of movement irrelevant
- BSP
- No published test of the brainspot hypotheses; no comparison of chosen and other eye positions
Randomized trials
- EMDR
- 76 trials in a 2020 meta-analysis, most in PTSD, few at low risk of bias
- BSP
- None in a clinical population; one non-randomized comparison, one uncontrolled study and single-session experiments
Guideline position for PTSD
- EMDR
- Recommended by NICE for adults after non-combat trauma and by the VA/DoD guideline; conditionally by the APA
- BSP
- Not among the treatments recommended by NICE
Main open question
- EMDR
- Whether the eye movements add anything to attending to the memory
- BSP
- Whether any effect goes beyond attending to a distressing memory in a supportive session
EMDR
- Developer and date
- Francine Shapiro; first published in 1989 as eye movement desensitization
- What the eyes do
- Repeated rhythmic eye movements, or alternating taps or tones, while the memory is held in mind
- Target of treatment
- Specific traumatic memories, processed within an eight-phase protocol
- Developers’ proposed mechanism
- Adaptive information processing, in which dysfunctionally stored memories are integrated with adaptive information
- Independent mechanism research
- Laboratory studies attribute the effect to the working memory load of a dual task, with the direction of movement irrelevant
- Randomized trials
- 76 trials in a 2020 meta-analysis, most in PTSD, few at low risk of bias
- Guideline position for PTSD
- Recommended by NICE for adults after non-combat trauma and by the VA/DoD guideline; conditionally by the APA
- Main open question
- Whether the eye movements add anything to attending to the memory
BSP
- Developer and date
- David Grand, in 2003, drawing on his EMDR practice and training in somatic experiencing
- What the eyes do
- The gaze is held still on one eye position, a brainspot, found by moving a pointer across the visual field
- Target of treatment
- The eye position linked to bodily activation, rather than the memory itself
- Developers’ proposed mechanism
- Midbrain pathways to the thalamus and cortex that are said to reset the orienting response to a traumatic memory
- Independent mechanism research
- No published test of the brainspot hypotheses; no comparison of chosen and other eye positions
- Randomized trials
- None in a clinical population; one non-randomized comparison, one uncontrolled study and single-session experiments
- Guideline position for PTSD
- Not among the treatments recommended by NICE
- Main open question
- Whether any effect goes beyond attending to a distressing memory in a supportive session
Eye movement desensitization and reprocessing (EMDR) and brainspotting are trauma therapies that give the eyes a role in treatment. In EMDR the client holds a distressing memory in mind while following sets of eye movements, or alternating taps or tones, within an eight-phase protocol[1][2]. In brainspotting the therapist guides the client’s eyes to a single position, the brainspot, at which the response to a distressing memory is felt most strongly, and the client holds that gaze while attending to what arises[3][4]. Each therapy has its own entry.
The two are related by descent. Grand developed brainspotting in 2003 from his work with EMDR and his training in somatic experiencing[3] . They are not variants of one technique, however, because they disagree about what the eyes are for: movement in EMDR, a fixed position in brainspotting.
Movement and fixed gaze
The procedural difference is the clearest one. EMDR uses repeated sets of eye movements while the client attends to a target memory, and the NICE guideline specifies repeated bilateral stimulation on specific memories until they are no longer distressing[2]. Brainspotting holds the gaze still. Its starting observation, as Grand and Corrigan describe it, is that the bodily activation felt when describing a traumatic event has a resonating spot in the visual field[4].
The target differs accordingly. EMDR’s target is the memory, worked through in phases that run from history taking and preparation to desensitization, installation of a positive belief and reassessment[1]. In brainspotting the target is the eye position, and the memory is approached through it[3].
Two sets of mechanism claims
Both developers proposed mechanisms, and in neither case have the proposals been confirmed. Shapiro’s adaptive information processing model holds that most disorders not caused by organic factors rest on memories stored in a dysfunctional form, which processing integrates with more adaptive information[1]. Grand and Corrigan proposed that focusing on a brainspot engages pathways from the retina through the superior colliculi to the thalamus and cortex, and that healing occurs in the midbrain when the orienting response to the memory is reset[4][5].
The difference lies in what has been tested. EMDR’s eye movements have been studied in laboratory experiments that do not depend on the developer’s model. These suggest that eye movements reduce the vividness and emotional intensity of memories by taxing working memory, and that vertical movements, or tasks with no eye movements at all, work as well as horizontal ones[6][7]. The brainspotting hypotheses were published as hypotheses, and the studies of brainspotting do not compare a chosen brainspot with any other eye position[4][8][3].
The asymmetry of evidence
The evidence for the two therapies is very different in size. A 2020 meta-analysis found 76 randomized trials of EMDR, most in PTSD, with an effect of g = 0.93 against control conditions; it also found that only 4 of 27 studies had a low risk of bias, and concluded that EMDR may be effective for PTSD in the short term[9]. A network meta-analysis for the NICE guideline found EMDR among the most effective treatments for adult PTSD, on evidence of moderate to low quality[10]. NICE recommends offering EMDR to adults with PTSD after non-combat trauma[2], and the 2023 VA/DoD guideline recommends it alongside prolonged exposure and cognitive processing therapy[11] .
Brainspotting has no randomized trial in a clinical population. The published studies are a comparison with EMDR whose abstract does not report random assignment[8], an uncontrolled study of 13 women[12] and a single-session experiment with trainee therapists[3]. It is not among the treatments NICE recommends[2].
Direct comparisons
The two therapies have been compared in two studies. In the clinical comparison, co-authored by Grand, 76 adults received three sessions of EMDR or brainspotting. Both groups improved on self-reported PTSD symptoms, with effect sizes of 1.19 to 1.76 for EMDR and 0.74 to 1.04 for brainspotting[8]. In the experiment with 40 trainee therapists, single 40-minute sessions of EMDR and of brainspotting each left distress about an ordinary memory lower than body scan meditation or book reading[3]. Neither study was designed to show that one therapy is better than the other.
What the comparison cannot settle
The uneven evidence does not show that brainspotting is ineffective; it shows that its effects have not been tested to the standard EMDR has met. Nor does EMDR’s trial record settle its own mechanism. Dismantling studies disagree about whether its eye movements add anything to attention to the memory[13][14], and the brainspotting studies have not addressed the equivalent question for a fixed gaze[8][3]. A reader comparing the two is comparing a treatment with a substantial, if imperfect, trial base and guideline support against a newer method whose evidence so far consists of small, mostly uncontrolled studies.
Sources14
Numbered in order of first citation.
- 1.Shapiro, F. (2014). The role of eye movement desensitization and reprocessing (EMDR) therapy in medicine: Addressing the psychological and physical symptoms stemming from adverse life experiences. The Permanente Journal, 18(1), 71–77. https://doi.org/10.7812/TPP/13-098
- 2.National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (2018). Post-traumatic stress disorder (NICE guideline NG116). National Institute for Health and Care Excellence. www.nice.org.uk/guidance/ng116
- 3.D'Antoni, F., Matiz, A., Fabbro, F., & Crescentini, C. (2022). Psychotherapeutic techniques for distressing memories: A comparative study between EMDR, brainspotting, and body scan meditation. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 19(3), 1142. https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph19031142
- 4.Corrigan, F., & Grand, D. (2013). Brainspotting: Recruiting the midbrain for accessing and healing sensorimotor memories of traumatic activation. Medical Hypotheses, 80(6), 759–766. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.mehy.2013.03.005
- 5.Corrigan, F. M., Grand, D., & Raju, R. (2015). Brainspotting: Sustained attention, spinothalamic tracts, thalamocortical processing, and the healing of adaptive orientation truncated by traumatic experience. Medical Hypotheses, 84(4), 384–394. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.mehy.2015.01.028
- 6.Andrade, J., Kavanagh, D., & Baddeley, A. (1997). Eye‐movements and visual imagery: A working memory approach to the treatment of post‐traumatic stress disorder. British Journal of Clinical Psychology, 36(2), 209–223. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.2044-8260.1997.tb01408.x
- 7.van den Hout, M. A., & Engelhard, I. M. (2012). How does EMDR work?. Journal of Experimental Psychopathology, 3(5), 724–738. https://doi.org/10.5127/jep.028212
- 8.Hildebrand, A., Grand, D., & Stemmler, M. (2017). Brainspotting – the efficacy of a new therapy approach for the treatment of posttraumatic stress disorder in comparison to eye movement desensitization and reprocessing. Mediterranean Journal of Clinical Psychology. openalex.org/works/W2613551630
- 9.Cuijpers, P., Veen, S. C. V., Sijbrandij, M., Yoder, W., & Cristea, I. A. (2020). Eye movement desensitization and reprocessing for mental health problems: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Cognitive Behaviour Therapy, 49(3), 165–180. https://doi.org/10.1080/16506073.2019.1703801
- 10.Mavranezouli, I., Megnin-Viggars, O., Daly, C., Dias, S., Welton, N. J., Stockton, S., Bhutani, G., Grey, N., Leach, J., Greenberg, N., Katona, C., El-Leithy, S., & Pilling, S. (2020). Psychological treatments for post-traumatic stress disorder in adults: a network meta-analysis. Psychological Medicine, 50(4), 542–555. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0033291720000070
- 11.Schnurr, P. P., Hamblen, J. L., Wolf, J., Coller, R., Collie, C., Fuller, M. A., Holtzheimer, P. E., Kelly, U., Lang, A. J., McGraw, K., Morganstein, J. C., Norman, S. B., Papke, K., Petrakis, I., Riggs, D., Sall, J. A., Shiner, B., Wiechers, I., & Kelber, M. S. (2024). The management of posttraumatic stress disorder and acute stress disorder: Synopsis of the 2023 U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs and U.S. Department of Defense Clinical Practice Guideline. Annals of Internal Medicine, 177(3), 363–374. https://doi.org/10.7326/M23-2757
- 12.Palsimon Jr., T. (2022). The preliminary efficacy and clinical applicability of Brainspotting among Filipino women with severe posttraumatic stress disorder. Archives of Psychiatry and Psychotherapy, 24(1), 54–64. https://doi.org/10.12740/app/143015
- 13.Davidson, P. R., & Parker, K. C. H. (2001). Eye movement desensitization and reprocessing (EMDR): A meta-analysis. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 69(2), 305–316. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-006X.69.2.305
- 14.Lee, C. W., & Cuijpers, P. (2013). A meta-analysis of the contribution of eye movements in processing emotional memories. Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry, 44(2), 231–239. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jbtep.2012.11.001
Related entries 5
Cite this entry
APA 7
Psych Dictionary. (2026, October 19). EMDR vs brainspotting. In Psych Dictionary. https://www.psychdictionary.com/compare/emdr-vs-brainspotting
MLA 9
“EMDR vs Brainspotting.” Psych Dictionary, 19 Oct. 2026, www.psychdictionary.com/compare/emdr-vs-brainspotting.